Maps of Power

Ćurčić 2010

Properties

ID 134190
System Class Bibliography
Bibliography Book
Case Study The Process of Byzantinization in the Central Balkans (Late 10th – Mid-13th Century)

Description

Slobodan Ćurčić, Architecture in the Balkans, from Diocletian to Süleyman the Magnificent (Princeton 2010).

Relations

Places (3)
Name Class Begin End Description
Kavadarci, Drenovo, The Church of the Virgin Mary Place The church dedicated to Virgin is located near the village of Drenovo (Дреново), about 13 kilometers west of Kavadarci. Architecture: The Church of the Virgin in Drenova has not been preserved in its authentic form. The biggest renovation of the church took place at the beginning of the 19th century, when the northern and western walls of the church were rebuilt, and the southern wall was lowered. At the same time, a wooden gallery was built on the west side. Despite these changes to the original construction, it is possible to reconstruct the original architectural structure of the building. From the point of view of architectural typology, the church is a very interesting achievement. It is a special combination of a basilica and a church of the inscribed cross. The base of the inscribed cross has a nave, with a dome resting on massive pilasters, which are connected on the south, north and west sides by two-arched passages supported by columns. On the eastern side, there is a spacious altar space, the apse of which is semicircular on the inside, and five-sided on the outside. The space below the dome is surrounded on three sides by aisled spaces which ends on the eastern part with pastophoria. The side aisles of the ambulatory had galleries. The central aisle of the western part of the ambulatory, that is, the narthex, was also surmounted by a dome, or blind calotte. Sculptural Decoration: A certain part of the original sculptural decoration has been preserved in the Church of the Virgin in Drenova. The first group within the architectural sculpture of the church consists of spolia, probably taken from the nearby early Christian basilica in Mutičanski dol. The second group includes the sculptures that are still in the church today (a fragment built into the north jamb of the west door, the mullion of an altar bifora, the capitals of the columns, etc.), as well as the fragments that are kept in the Archaeological Museum in Sofia. The fragments are decorated with floral motifs, crosses and fantastic animals (griffins, lions). On the basis of stylistic peculiarities, i.e. the closest analogies (sculpture of the church of St. Sophia in Ohrid, fragments from the church of St. Stephen in Konča), the architectural sculpture from Drenovo is mostly dated to the 11th century. Moreover, it was assumed that the sculpture from Drenovo and Konče were made by the same workshop. Dating: On the basis of the presented architectural features of the church, i.e. the stylistic features of the sculptural decoration, the prevailing opinion in the scientific literature is that it is a monument of Byzantine architecture of the 11th century. In recent times, however, a different opinion has been expressed about the time of the creation of the church in Drenovo. Contrary to the views of her predecessors, Marica Šuput believes that the church was built in the fifth or sixth decade of the 14th century. She claims, that it could be the endowment of a Serbian nobleman from the time of king/emperor Dušan. In doing so, the author has in mind first of all the architectural features of the building, to which she finds the closest analogies in the church of the Virgin Olimpiotissa in Elassona, built in the second quarter of the mentioned century. Apart from that, Šuput believes that certain examples of architectural plastic due to their stylistic peculiarities belong to the art of the 14th century, which, although without explanation, was also considered by some earlier researchers (G. Petrov). Furthermore, Marica Šuput also takes into account the content of the very damaged fresco-inscription above the southern entrance to the building, in which, according to the reading of Radoslav Grujić, published by Vojislav Radovanović, is mentioned painter Dimitar who decorated the church in the time of emperor Stefan. Finally, the author draws attention to the fact that in 1378 Konstantin Dragaš donated a church to the monastery of Saint Panteleimon on Mount Athos.
Prilep, Church of Saint Nicholas Place Description The Church of St. Nicholas is located in the medieval lower town of Prilep (today Varoš). It is situated a few hundred meters away from the medieval marketplace, at the foot of the medieval fortress known as the "Markovi kuli." It is a small single-aisled building with an externally three-sided apse. The lower part of the building is constructed with roughly cut stone, including spolia, while the upper part is built of stone and brick. The significant differences in construction and treatment between the lower and upper parts of the facades are the result of two construction phases. The frescoes inside the Church of St. Nicholas consist of two stylistically different parts, found in the altar apse and the nave. The dedicatory inscription above the southern doors of the church reveals that the frescoes in the nave were commissioned by Vego Kapza and his wife Maria in 1298. Architecture The first phase of construction: The high stone base belongs to the first construction phase of the Church of St. Nicholas (2.6m), made of rough-hewn stone of various dimensions and several rectangular marble blocks used as spolia. These are the remains of a small single-aisled church, built with rough stone. Parallels: In the older layer of the building, there are no stylistic or any other elements that could clearly indicate the construction period. The simplicity of their plan and the construction material suggest that they were built by local craftsmen. Similarities have been observed with objects of domestic architecture from the second half of the 12th century, whose remains have been found in the area of the present-day settlement of Varoš. Dating: end of the 12th century The second phase of construction: The upper part of the church, set on a high stone base, corresponds to the second construction phase. The predominant characteristic of the interior space is the dominance of height over the length of the church. The facade surfaces are entirely covered with ceramic plastic decoration. The quality of the exterior is emphasized by continuous horizontal bands made of various brick motifs, representing a distinctive feature of late Byzantine, and particularly Epirote architecture. Parallels: St. John Kaneo in Ohrid; the Church of the Theotokos Peribleptos in Ohrid; the Church of Christ the Savior in Borje, near Korcha (Koresha), Albania; Panagia (the Panagia Kyriotissa and Ag. Theodoroi) in Preventza, Greece; Ag. Vassileios stin Gefyra in Arta, the Narthex of the Church of Ag. Theodora in Arta. Dating: ca. 1285-1295 Painted Decoration The first fresco unit: consists of frescoes in the altar apse and the lunette of the western facade. A conservative artistic approach was applied, based on expressive means inherited from the Comnenian art, but adapted in a provincial spirit of the second half of the 13th century. Parallels: St. John Kaneo in Ohrid; the Church of St. Nicholas in the village of Manastir in Mariovo; the Church of St. Demetrios in Prilep; the Church of St. George Omorphoklisias near Kastoria Dating: third quarter of the 13th century, or 1298 The second fresco unit: consists of frescoes in the naos. The work of the two painters has been assessed as a fusion of old and new concepts during the stylistically transitional period of the late 13th century. Parallels: Virgin Mavriotissa in Kastoria; Vlacherna monastery in Arta; The Church of Archangel Michael in Kostaniani near Ioannina; the Church of Taxiarches in Kostaniani near Ioannina; Ag. Demetrios Katsouris in Plissioi near Arta. Dating: 1298
Prilep, the Church of Saint Demetrius Place The church St. Demetrius is located in the western part of Varoš, in the area that used to be the economic centre of the lower town of medieval Prilep. The village of Varoš, a suburb of Prilep, in the Middle Ages was in the vicinity of the fortress that Skilica calls Πρίλαπος τὸ φρούριον. In medieval sources, the church is mentioned only in the charter of Emperor Stefan Dušan from 1335 to the Treskavac monastery, in which he bequeathed the church as a gift to this monastery. One of the founders is also mentioned in the charter. The founder of the major additions from the 13th century was the Byzantine nobleman, Dimitrios Misinopolit. Architecture: Church of Saint Demetrius has a complex architectural composition and is preserved in its entirety with modifications over the centuries. The church represents a group of three churches separated from each other by massive walls built in the period from the 12th to the 14th century. The core of the church is the nave, which is placed in the direction of the east-west axis. Above the eastern part of the nave rises a dome placed on a drum, which is cylindrical inside and divided into twelve sides on the outside. The dome has nine narrow windows. On both sides (north and south) parallel to the main axis of the church, are placed two side annexes. The connection of the nave with the side annexes is achieved by means of two semicircular arched openings. All three spaces in the east end with an aps, while in the west they are connected with common narthex. The apse on the south side is three-sided, while the other two are semicircular on the outside. The external dimensions of the church are: to the east and west - 11.43 m, to the north - 13.65 m. and in the south - 13.95 m. The total height (from the floor in the nave to the summit of the dome) is 10.64 m. The constructive system of the church of St. Dimitrija contains all the essential features of the constructive systems of churches of the inscribed cross type with a dome. The facades with a variety of ceramoplastic decoration have a particular architectural value.The northern facade is the most representative. It was built in a typical Byzantine style of masonry, alternating between stone blocks and bricks. The checkerboard system, which is carried over to the northern apse, and the three bricked-up arched openings of the former porch with frames decorated with radially placed bricks, have been recorded. The northern facade is decorated with two toothed cornices, the higher of which extends to the eastern and western facades. The niches to the left and right of the window have bricks arranged in zig-zag lines. The southern facade has a lower part that is built of irregularly arranged stone blocks with the occasional use of brick. The higher parts are processed more meticulously with a combination of stone and brick. The apse of the central church and its upper parts, which represent the oldest part of the building, are the most roughly executed. The narthex suffered the most, where the southern side, which adjoins the southern wall of the church, has been preserved. The northern side has been preserved up to a height of half a meter. The northern annex of the church has the shape of an irregular quadrangle that ends in the east with a semicircular apse. The connection of the northern annex with the nave and the altar area is via two arched openings. It is also connected to the vestibule through an arched opening. The northern annex is entered from the outside through an opening on the northern facade of the church. The southern annex, like the northern one, consists of three sections in the east-west direction. It has the shape of an irregular quadrilateral. As with the northern annex, the upper structure is characterized by a transverse arch above the central nave, which is supported laterally by two arches above the eastern and western naves placed in the east-west direction. The connection with the nave is achieved through an arched opening. The floor in the southern annex is lower than the floor of the nave. The church undergone significant architectural changes, and it is an outstanding indicator of the general flows in the development of the church architecture on the wider territory of Macedonia in the late Byzantine period. Dating: First phase: Sašo Korunovski distinguishes four stages of church construction. In his opinion, the first single-nave church was built in the middle of the 12th century. Second phase: After Prilep came under the rule of John III Doukas Vatatzes (1221-1254) in 1246, an open porch was added from the north, which shows similarities with the architecture of the Nicaean Empire probably between 1260-1270 Third phase: In the third quarter of the 13th century, an open narthex was installed and the two resulting naves were covered with a transverse vault. Fourth phase: Finally, in the last decade of the 13th century, the church was rebuilt into an inscribed cross with a dome, the south nave and common narthex were added. The founder of all the undertakings of the fourth phase was Dimitrios Misinopolit, depicted on the founder’s composition. In the portrait he is not holding a model of the church in his hands. The text of the inscription above his head points out that he is the founder of the whole church and not just the added parts. Parallels: Epirus was certainly the most suitable area from where the type of churches with an overhanging cross vault could be transferred to Macedonia. This type will appear only in the third phase of construction at the church of Saint Demetrius. Some other specific Epirus motifs are also found in the church of St. Demetrius. On the south facade, above the windows, is a zig-zag frieze with triangular stones inserted into the gaps between the bricks. The dome of the Church of St. Demetrius also reveals motifs characteristic of the architecture of Epirus from the end of the 13th century. This type of dome was widely used in the 14th century and is linked to the influence of Thessaloniki architecture. However, as pointed out by the researchers, the earliest examples of such a drum design with windows reaching only to the middle with arched ends are known among the buildings such as the church of Panagia Parigoritisa in Arta, before 1294–1296, Archangel Michael in Berat, etc. Epigraphic data: Type and place of the first inscription: The first inscription is located in the southern nave, on the western part of the northern wall, it is displayed in three rows, in white on a blue background, above the portrait of Dimitrios Misinopolit. who addresses the patron saint of the church in prayer. Text of the first inscription: δέ(ησις) τοῦ δού[λου] τοῦ θ(εο)ῦ Δημητρίουa τοῦ Μησηνοπολήτου καὶ κτήτορ(ος)c τοῦ ναοῦ Translation of the first inscription: Petition of the servant of God Dimitrios of Misinopolit and the founder of the church. Type and place of the second inscription: The second inscription is on the western side of the altar column, it is written above the representation of the prophet Elijah, in one line, in red on a brown background. Text of the second inscription: [δέησις]a τοῦ δούλου τοῦ θ(εο)ῦ b [Ἀνδρο]νίκου καὶ Ἠρή[νη]ς a [Μνήσθητι Κύρι]ε Translation of the second inscription: Plea of the servant of God Andronikos and Irina. Painting: The church has preserved parts of paintings in the dome and area below the dome, on the walls of the nave and in the apse of the central church, as well as on the sides of the north and south arches that connects northern and southern annexes. In the annexes, as well as in the narthex, there are some badly damaged fragments. In the semi-calotte of the central apse is a representation of the Virgin Mary with Christ. The founding composition is painted on the north-western wall of the southern annex. Paintings in the dome and below the dome belong to the younger painting of the 14th century. At the top of the dome is Christ Pantokrator. The circle around it has seven medallions with representations of angels painted in bust supporting the sphere. Between the windows in the drum are representations of prophets. Three compositions have been preserved from the Great Feasts cycle: the Ascension, the Assumption of the Virgin Mary and the Annunciation. Painting dates: Vojislav Đurić dates the oldest painting, the scene with hetoimasia, in the apse to 1290, interpreting the style as a relapse of the Komnenian style of painting, connecting it to the layer of paintings from the 13th century. The same author attributes the youngest layer of paintings to the group of painters around Metropolitan Jovan, dating them to the period from the ninth decade of the 14th century to the third decade of the 15th century. He believes that Jovan followed the scheme of old painting during the renovation in the 14th century.